Is Zoella really a 'bad role model'?


I wouldn't usually post 2 thought-pieces in the same week but I've been weighing this one up in my head for a fair few days. I'm sure all of you by now will have come across that Independent Voices article. Bloggers everywhere, quite rightly, have reacted angrily towards the author's spiteful personal attack on Zoe, as well as her declarations that an interest in fashion and beauty is somehow anti-feminist (how very second-wave of you!) However is there any truth in the idea that Zoella is a bad role model for young girls?



Image via: youtube.com

I've thought about it and I don't think Zoe is a bad role model, I just think there are better role models out there. Zoe took the Youtube world by storm with a combination of her content, working on her brand, right place right time and being part of the Youtube social circle. However for young girls this happening for them is about as likely as them becoming the next Beyonce. Obviously I don't think it's the fault of celebrities that they were the one in a million to make it, however I think we would do well to teach girls to look to more attainable and worthy role models. This could be an army medic cousin or a friend's sister who raised thousands of pounds for charity or their older brother, the first person to go to university in their family.

I don't think celebrities can never be role models but they are the exception. We are very keen to label every star a role model regardless of whether their target audience is young girls or even when they've specifically said they don't want to be one (e.g. Rihanna). However I don't think celebrities are role models by default, I think they are when they use their fame to do something incredible. Angelina Jolie's humanitarian work, as well as her own personal decision to have preventative cancer surgery, was incredible. I'm not really into her style or acting but Emma Watson studied hard, went to university to better herself (despite Hollywood offers and being set for life financially) and is now UN Goodwill Ambassador for Women. A personal hero of mine growing up was J.K. Rowling, who went from being a single mother on benefits to a billionaire then back down to a millionaire because she donates so much to charity and pays her share of taxes. I am aware of the work Zoe has done with the mental health charity Mind and I think it is admirable, but I don't believe most of her fans would say that's one of the main reasons they aspire to be like her, though maybe I'll be eating my words on that in a year's time!

Those women were also one in a million who had a lot of talent and luck but I think the difference is that many teens see Youtube as a way to 'get rich and famous quick' (like it's the X Factor or something). Obviously a lot of work goes into making, editing and promoting videos (and some Youtubers work harder than others) but I think especially with vlogs young teenagers see the life of a Youtuber as waking up, getting some freebies in the post, buying expensive groceries, having a meeting in their apartment, walking the dog, meeting some friends for lunch, going shopping and buying £1000s worth of stuff, going out for dinner then bed. For me there's something a little troubling about young people aspiring to this lifestyle and they don't seem to understand the value of money. I don't think there's anything wrong with working hard and treating yourself (I do that plenty!) but I don't think that young teens understand the amount of work they'd have to put in to be able to spend like Estee or Amelia.

I don't think there's anything wrong with young girls enjoying Zoe's videos, admiring her personality, feeling like she's their friend or her videos helping them through the awkwardness that is puberty. If Zoe has inspired someone to get help when they're struggling or her attitude has given them a more positive outlook on life - great! The problem for me lies in the nature of Youtube (vlogging in particular). It makes this new breed of celebrity more accessible than ever and with that comes a young, impressionable fan base who aspire to imitate that sort of lifestyle. In reality I think they're better off looking closer to home for people to model themselves after and if they do look to celebrities they should admire a quality in a person, not their lifestyle or looks.

I definitely thought twice before posting this as I could see getting a lot of grief...I hope Zoe fans don't take offence and see where my argument is coming from! I'd like to hear your thoughts on role models and Youtube culture in the comments.



Don't forget to follow me on:

You may also like:

12 comments

  1. I really enjoyed reading your post. I love watching Zoe's main channel videos and vlogs, and I completely get what you mean by young girls perhaps aspiring for a life like Zoe's which isn't perhaps attainable for everyone, and there might be better role models out there. However, I do admire Zoe for vlogging on particular days in which she is not feeling her normal bubbly and happy self, and reflects that all of us have bad/sad days sometimes and that that's ok too!

    Very interesting read :)

    Rachel | Beauty & The Bird xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! She definitely has lots of admirable personality traits, I hope her less 'happy' vlogs go some way to showing people that even if you have that sort of lifestyle it doesn't solve all your problems xx

      Delete
  2. GREAT post, I agree with everthing that you said. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is a really great post - I definitely agree with your thoughts! I think the problem also lies in the fact that we're in the midst of YouTube becoming very mainstream. And YouTubers are transforming from the 'girl next door' you can relate to, to basically a celebrity with the celebrity lifestyle. I think some younger viewers might be unable to distinguish this change and still aspire to be like their 'friend' when really, their lifestyle has turned unattainable. I'm glad you didn't decide to not post this - great read!
    RosieLM - A Beauty(ish) Blog

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah I think the more rich and famous Youtuber become the less relatable they're going to become :/ xx

      Delete
  4. I think posts like this are great, I think people are too quick to jump on the hateful train if someone says just a tiny thing a tiny bit negative about Zoella. Everyone has a right to their opinion!

    daisychurchward.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. And I was very worried about getting stick for questioning something like this but everyone seems to be understand where I'm coming from. I guess the thing about having an opinion that may be a little unpopular is you have to put it across well xx

      Delete
  5. Well I have to say this has passed me by somewhat - I know nothing of the context of your post but I think you're right about role models though x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! There was a big thing last week about a journalist criticising Zoella for being a bad role model because she talks about hair and makeup x

      Delete
  6. I'm so glad I came across this post which I missed before. Your approach to the subject matter is one that I can relate to and akin to my own perspective on such things. I also revealed in the opportunity to get to know you better. I read another post the other day which talked about how much personal information is shared in blogging and vlogging world - and the writer raised many points which I agreed with, but she also said something that stuck with me "you can tell a lot about a person by the way they write". And I completely agreed, without knowing personal facts or even seeing someone's photograph, you can develop impressions and understandings based on their wring style,. Anyway, the point of all of that is to say that how you wrote this, told me a lot about you in a positive, meaningful way. :-) xo

    Beauty Isles | An Island Girl's Beauty and Lifestyle Blog

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aww thank you :) I'm glad you appreciated the post. I'm not a big sharer in terms of my personal life but hopefully my personality comes across in my writing! xx

      Delete

Thank you for your comment - I read every single one!

Though I may not be able to reply to each individual comment, I always check out the blogs of people who leave genuine comments and comment back as much as possible (so please do not spam!)

If you have a question please check back for my reply or tweet me @jasminetalksblg

xx

© Jasmine Talks Beauty. Design by MangoBlogs.