Makeup Revolution Iconic 3 Redemtion Eyeshadow Palette Review

When I first looked into the Urban Decay Naked palettes, Naked 3 was the one which appealed to me most in the pan but I was unsure if it would suit me. The woman in the shop said 'that's for blonde people really', so I was put right off it. However soon after this I heard about the Iconic 3 palette, a £4 dupe of Naked 3 (the only shade-by-shade dupe I'm aware of). With such a tiny price tag I decided to take the plunge and try rose shades I'd never normally have looked into.

I kind of felt like Naked 2 was much of a muchness, and if you owned 1 you didn't really need it, however 3 is completely different. Whilst I don't own 3, so can't do a direct comparison, I can compare the quality of the Naked palette I do own to Makeup Revolution's effort. 

First off is the packaging; it's nothing special but it's functional. It fastens securely and I've dropped it a fair few times and it's remained unharmed! The reason I like MUA and Makeup Revolution over other high-quality, super-affordable brands is that the products don't look or feel cheap. The packaging is sleek and simple and I like that you can see which colours are inside! I slightly prefer a round eyeshadow pan, but that's personal preference! For some reason they look bigger, but I checked and the MUR palettes are bigger than the MUA ones in weight as well as in size. 

So onto the shades; I'm honestly really happy the £4 price-tag allowed me to experiment with these colours! I never would have paid £37 for something so out of my comfort zone, but they are just lovely. If you're not pale and blonde, seriously do not be put off these shades. If anything I feel as though the colours pop more on medium skin-tones. They're just beautiful; the first 6 shades are more light champagne and baby pink colours, whereas the the second 6 are more mauve and plum colours. I thought the colour pay-off for all but the lightest shade was fantastic, and apart from one or two of the shimmers there was very little fallout. 

So here is a side-by side comparison (Image of Naked 3 via: urbandecay.com)

The shades don't have names, which is a shame, so I'm just going to label them 1-12 from left to right (so the lightest is 1 and the darkest is 2). 1 is your highlight shade; a pinkish-cream matte. 2 is a shimmery champagne and 3 is quite similar but a darker, rosier tone. 4 is a medium pink matte, 5 is a silvery-pink shimmer and 6 is a gold-toned orange shimmer. Onto the second half: 7 is a light grey matte, 8 is a pink-grey shimmer and 9 is a pinkish taupe shimmer. 10 is more grey-toned pink shimmer, 11 is a grey-mauve shimmer and finally 12 is a black-purple shimmer. 

So here are the swatches! As always there is one with a flash (on the left for both) and one without (on the right for both). The first set shows shades 1-6 (starting with 1 at the top) and the second set shows shades 7-12 (starting with 7 on the top).

I've applied 4 swipes with each, so that should give you an idea of the pigmentation (I think 7-12 are more pigmented than the lighter shades). As always this is all without a primer! As you can see, even shades which seem similar in the pan don't look same-y at all when swatched. My favourites from the lighter side are shades 3, 4 and 6 and from the darker end, 8, 9 and 10.

So here is the look I created with it! I like to test dupes by seeing if I can follow YT tutorials for the original and I think that (my inferior application aside!) I managed it with Iconic 3. This is the tutorial I followed: I blended 4 into the crease, dotted 10 across my lid, put 8 on top of it, blended 7 into the crease and 11 then 12 went onto my outer corner (and I blended them into the crease a bit). I then put a bit of 3 on the very inner corner, highlighted with 1 and patted a bit of 6 in the centre of my lid. I really love the colours and I'm so happy with this look :)

It stayed really nicely. I used the e.l.f. Eyelid Primer in Sheer (£1.95) and it stayed nicely for 6 hours. After this point it started to blur a little but the look still remained and it didn't crease! Obviously it's not Urban Decay but it comes far closer than a lot of other premium brands do, as far as quality goes. It's fairly easy to just copy the colours of Naked 3, but to get the quality so high for £4 is seriously impressive.

Overall I love this palette and I'm so glad I tried something new with these colours. It's one of those one's I'd have paid 4x the amount for and I'd still think I'd got a good deal. I'd recommend this to a lot of different skin-tones; don't be scared of the pink! I think the question you have to ask yourself is, 'do you think the Urban Decay version is £33 better?', if it's a 'no' I'd say this is a great alternative, or even if you plan on buying the Urban Decay, it's a great way to test out if the shades are for you.



* Durable
* Beautiful selection of 12 complimentary shades
* £4!!!!!!!!!!!
* High quality
* All but one or two shades have excellent pigmentation
* All but a couple have virtually no fall-out 
* A mix of shimmers and mattes
* Easy to blend
* Easy to apply
* Packaging is sturdy and functional and doesn't look £4


* Might be a little limited in how many looks you can create
* I'd have liked Shade 1 to have been more pigmented

The Verdict

Durability:                  ****
Finish:                      ****.5
Colour pay-off:          ****
Colour selection:        ****
Finish selection:         ****
General Quality:     ****.5
Versatility:                  ***
Value for Money:    *****




  1. I've done a review on another Revolution palette which you can view here:

    Just followed you!! Hope you can drop by my blog and perhaps follow back?

    Lucy // Lucys Life Through a Lense

  2. Love those colours, they're so pretty :)

  3. I didn't have any of them so bought the 2nd naked palette as I thought it was a bit more versatile for work. But now looking at this I kinda want the 3rd now... But would be tempted to try this dupe version instead as the colours look good! Thanks for the tip!

  4. I really love this look on you, so very pretty! I'm dying to buy alot of this makeup! Roll on payday! I'm also still tempted to get the Urban Decay palette as I love the second one!

  5. Thank you! And yes I love my Urban Decay Naked 1, I'm really glad there are such good dupes to test out before committing £37 :)


Thank you for your comment - I read and appreciate every single one :)

There's no need to spam - I will check out your blog if you leave a click-able link under a genuine comment!

If you have a question please check back for my reply or tweet me @jasminetalksblg


© Jasmine Talks Beauty | All rights reserved.
Blog Layout Created by pipdig